Pick 6 Most Overrated Ryan songs

[roshea999]

Originally Posted by Shadowlands96

"Damn Sam (I Love a Woman That Rains)"
"The Rescue Blues"
"Afraid Not Scared"
"Goodnight Rose"

Couldn't disagree more haha.

Afraid Not Scared in particular - I wish he still wrote songs like that.

[GoodSkanky]

Originally Posted by Electricityscape

There is in their catalogue nothing better than than their trilogy Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, A Ghost Is Born and Sky Blue Sky. You don't like that last one Loveishello86?

Being There, Summerteeth, to YHF is my Wilco trilogy. I still like most of Ghost and Sky Blue Sky. S/t is pretty good too. After that... meh.

[Shadowlands96]

Originally Posted by roshea999

Couldn't disagree more haha.

Afraid Not Scared in particular - I wish he still wrote songs like that.

Mind you, I don't hate those songs by any means. They're just generally highly-regarded ones that don't really do it for me.

[Loveishello86]

Originally Posted by Electricityscape

There is in their catalogue nothing better than than their trilogy Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, A Ghost Is Born and Sky Blue Sky. You don't like that last one Loveishello86?

na i actually like sky blue sky but people seem to hate it or think its basically dad rock.

[The Black Map]

Originally Posted by GoodSkanky

Being There, Summerteeth, to YHF is my Wilco trilogy. I still like most of Ghost and Sky Blue Sky. S/t is pretty good too. After that... meh.

Funny, my trilogy is Summerteeth --> YHF --> Ghost.

[DRG]

Not necessarily "overrated", but Ryan songs that I have never taken to...

Outbound Train (plus the vast majority of Prisoner, but this is the worst)
Fix It
Shadows
Enemy Fire
No Shadow
Desire

[sleigher]

all of them

[sleigher]

Originally Posted by GoodSkanky

Jesus, Don't Touch My Baby (piss poor attempt to get an arty Radiohead thing going

Originally Posted by sleigher

that song is his tribute to american music club and i will always love him for that

well - maybe not always

[Teenie Smith-Macbeth]

Originally Posted by sleigher

well - maybe not always

I dunno, it says it right there “I will ALWAYS LOVE HIM”

tough spot

[GoodSkanky]

Originally Posted by The Black Map

Funny, my trilogy is Summerteeth --> YHF --> Ghost.

Solid choices. I do like the tension and release of Kidsmoke, but found that they did it the same live as on the album, which made the effectiveness of it kind of trite. I always skip that big pause before the last tune too.

[The Lizard King]

Do You Still Love Me
Gimme Something Good
Lucky Now

[seatakestheship]

Originally Posted by GoodSkanky

Being There, Summerteeth, to YHF is my Wilco trilogy. I still like most of Ghost and Sky Blue Sky. S/t is pretty good too. After that... meh.

Absolutely. The Jay Bennett years were prime Wilco.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Pooydatigru]

Invisible Riverside
Oh My Sweet Carolina
New York, New York
Do You Still Love Me?
So Alive

[raisemyglass]

I am going to blow torch this thread and say Cold Roses is Ryan's most overrated album, the only thing more overrated was the band that inspired it, and the influx of deadheads was the worst thing to happen (outside of the current findings) to the RA fan base.

[Loveishello86]

Originally Posted by raisemyglass

I am going to blow torch this thread and say Cold Roses is Ryan's most overrated album, the only thing more overrated was the band that inspired it, and the influx of deadheads was the worst thing to happen (outside of the current findings) to the RA fan base.

Is cold roses overrated to you because you don't like the grateful dead?

[thebambino]

Originally Posted by raisemyglass

I am going to blow torch this thread and say Cold Roses is Ryan's most overrated album, the only thing more overrated was the band that inspired it, and the influx of deadheads was the worst thing to happen (outside of the current findings) to the RA fan base.

if there’s one person i don’t trust, it’s someone who actively hates the dead.

[Harry656]

Come Pick Me Up
To Be Young
Answering Bell
Out of the Woods
Shake It Off
If I Am A Stranger

[Loveishello86]

Originally Posted by Harry656

Come Pick Me Up
To Be Young
Answering Bell
Out of the Woods
Shake It Off
If I Am A Stranger

is shake it off highly rated ?